INDEPENDENT CHECK: MB VOTING HISTORY, SAVED A1–A283 CORPUS
23 October 2026. Local primary-record verification only; no network refresh.

ANSWER
Yes. The earlier MB-associated board wallet cast a successful NO vote on A28, '[pdt] Transfer 40k LUNA for Long Term Alignment Program', on 24 October 2024 at 01:50:21 UTC. The statement 'MB has never voted NO' is false for the combined two-account history in this corpus. The narrower statement 'the current MB wallet has no recorded NO in captured A1–A283' is supported.

EXACT NO-VOTE TRANSACTION
Transaction: 338EEF5869DF3B356439C7E6FF6DFFC1417ED91F309E54B863B95D66FFBD1B07
Timestamp: 2024-10-24T01:50:21Z
Height: 12637738
Result code: 0 (successful)
Sender: terra15vwmgac9tlcgkrkjn4rq3r0md003ufsqp64vaw
Contract: terra1660g9mle5kfsq8c0p4k4hgr9ujdyr3m48c22cawy0akr98rmwksqehqnup
Message: {"vote":{"proposal_id":28,"vote":"no"}}
Public locator: https://chainsco.pe/terra2/tx/338EEF5869DF3B356439C7E6FF6DFFC1417ED91F309E54B863B95D66FFBD1B07
Primary file: sources/vote_transactions/archive_module_vote_page1.body
Pointer: /tx_responses/87/tx/body/messages/0; response timestamp, height, code and hash are at /tx_responses/87.
File SHA-256: 8ba8af713c2aab36ad24e97452c0577855fd08c5bde6ec4a67377f32bfffd977

A28's recorded description says LUNA would be locked with an auto-max lock and distributed as locks to Veto Multisig participants. Captured final state: closed; YES 25, NO 50, ABSTAIN 0. Rose and the earlier MB-associated wallet recorded NO; Philipp YES; Vini no recorded ballot. Proposal creation was 23 October 2024 at 20:48:17.527444552 UTC, which is not the vote timestamp. The recorded ballot contains no rationale, so the NO vote alone does not establish MB's reason.

INDEPENDENT RECOMPUTATION
Used review.json solely as the source index. Reopened every one of its 283 primary ballot bodies, verified each SHA-256, read the actual votes, independently traversed every proposal-source JSON pointer, checked titles/proposers and reconciled ballot-power sums with proposal tallies. All IDs A1–A283 are present. Zero hash, ballot, proposer, title or tally discrepancies. Searched all nine archive_module_vote_page*.body files for NO votes by either MB-associated address: the A28 transaction above is the only match in that saved archive.

Earlier MB-associated account: terra15vwmgac9tlcgkrkjn4rq3r0md003ufsqp64vaw
Observed voting window A1–A125: 118 ballots = 117 YES, 1 NO, 0 ABSTAIN; seven proposals without a recorded ballot (A62, A63, A72, A73, A74, A75, A92).
Current MB account: terra1vv9zaygt7csc4wnufwk4snq2jle2sdh73vml73
Observed voting window A126–A283: 131 ballots = 131 YES, 0 NO, 0 ABSTAIN; 27 proposals without a recorded ballot.
Combined across the distinct windows: 249 ballots = 248 YES, 1 NO, 0 ABSTAIN; 34 of the 283 proposals have no recorded MB ballot. There is no overlap/double count between these two observed voting windows.

AGREEMENT WITH PHILIPP
Earlier account: 117 proposals with ballots from both; 113 same (all YES/YES), four different:
  A28: Philipp YES / MB NO.
  A57: Philipp NO / MB YES. Title: [axelar-recovery] Setup OTC (CoinGecko: 0.40399, 91413.00000).
  A58: Philipp NO / MB YES. Title: [pdt] Setup OTC (CoinGecko: 0.40399, 91413.00000).
  A85: Philipp ABSTAIN / MB YES. Title: [pdt] Setup Boost DAO Project Grant.
Current account: 119 proposals with ballots from both; 119 same, all YES/YES.
Combined: 236 shared ballots; 232 same; four divergences. This refutes an unqualified claim that they have always voted the same way. Missing ballots are not ABSTAIN votes. Shared YES votes do not establish coordination, following instructions or the motivation behind a vote.

PROPOSER MIX
Across all 283 primary proposal records, Philipp's address is recorded as proposer of 282; Vini's address is recorded as proposer only on A249, the Atrium security-audit funding proposal.
All 118 earlier-account ballots concerned Philipp-proposed proposals.
Current-account ballots: 130 on Philipp-proposed proposals plus one YES on Vini-proposed A249.
Combined recorded MB ballots: 248 on Philipp-proposed proposals (247 YES, one NO) plus one YES on Vini-proposed A249. All 119 current-account shared YES cases were Philipp-proposed. Proposal authorship is not proof of who originated every idea or performed every preparatory task.

ACCOUNT TRANSITION
Independently decoded A125's executed update_members message: remove terra15vwmgac9tlcgkrkjn4rq3r0md003ufsqp64vaw and add terra1vv9zaygt7csc4wnufwk4snq2jle2sdh73vml73 with weight 25. This provides a direct membership-transition link. The A125 description is only '.', so human attribution/exclusive custody should still cite the existing attribution evidence rather than treating that description as a named admission.
Primary: sources/prior/proposals_page002.body, /data/proposals/24/proposal/msgs/0.

SCOPE AND REUSE
This verifies the historical captured A1–A283 corpus, with proposals created through 14 October 2026, using the 11/16 October source set indexed by the historical source index (all primary ballot files are included here). The preparing agent is refreshing later records separately. These numbers are not asserted as a complete 23 October live snapshot or a record of every board, native-governance or separate-company vote MB has ever cast.

23 OCTOBER DELTA: A284–A289 INDEPENDENTLY VERIFIED
The historical counts above are retained for their defined A1–A283 window. This update supersedes them for the expanded captured A1–A289 set.
Reopened raw/A_latest.body and each raw/ballots_A284.body through ballots_A289.body. All six ballot-file hashes match their capture metadata; all six ballot-power sums reconcile with proposal tallies. Captures are 23 October 2026, 08:27:46–08:27:53 UTC, heights 23414807–23414808. All six proposals identify Philipp as proposer.
  A284: MB YES; Philipp ABSTAIN. Title: [asset-staking] Whitelist 0, Remove 1.
  A285: no recorded MB ballot; Philipp YES.
  A286: MB YES; Philipp YES.
  A287: MB YES; Philipp YES.
  A288: no recorded MB ballot; Philipp NO.
  A289: MB YES; Philipp YES.

EXPANDED COUNTS (CAPTURED A1–A289)
Earlier account is unchanged: 118 ballots, 117 YES / 1 NO / 0 ABSTAIN, seven no-recorded-ballot cases in A1–A125.
Current account in A126–A289 (164 proposals): 135 ballots, all YES, 29 no-recorded-ballot cases.
Combined: 253 ballots, 252 YES / 1 NO / 0 ABSTAIN; 36 proposals with no recorded MB ballot.
Current-account shared ballots with Philipp: 123; 122 same (YES/YES), one divergence (A284 YES/ABSTAIN).
Combined-account shared ballots with Philipp: 240; 235 same, five divergences (A28, A57, A58, A85, A284).
Expanded proposer mix: 288 Philipp, one Vini (A249). Combined MB ballots on Philipp-proposed proposals: 252 (251 YES, one NO); one YES on Vini-proposed A249.

Therefore, '119 out of 119' remains valid only for the earlier explicitly bounded A1–A283/current-wallet comparison. It is no longer a complete description of the current wallet's captured history. The refreshed record contains a current-wallet divergence on A284. Missing ballots remain distinct from explicit abstention.
